Comparing vinyl records to CD’s and digital audio files – Song Director

Here is a good article comparing vinyl records to CD and digital audio files

Song Director Music Database Software for Windows can Catalog and organize your digital music collection.   Download it for free here



I’m sure you heard about the
resurgence of vinyl or possibly
perused the Billboard cover story on the marriage of vinyl and digital. It’s true, vinyl is back… not that it ever went anywhere, but in a time when physical music sales are shrinking, vinyl is experiencing a real period of growth.

From vinyl’s big comeback to the time restrictions of a 45 RPM 7”.
Hopefully you will find this helpful as you’re putting together your first or next vinyl project. Enjoy.
vinyl, it’s the new vinyl!
These days one of the most common questions I get is what is causing the big vinyl comeback? Oddly enough I don’t think it’s what happened to vinyl that’s causing the comeback, it’s what happened to digital. First, for many audiophiles and DJs, vinyl never went away. For others, such as myself, it’s the emergence of the MP3 that brought vinyl back. Plain and simple, there’s no need for discs to be compact any longer so some folks are ditching their CDs in favor of the warmth of vinyl and the convenience of MP3. CD has its advantages and if there was only one format, CD would probably make the most sense as you get a tangible item, artwork and a reasonable level of compactness. That said, with the emergence of digital, things have changed and the ideal situation now seems to be having your iPod or MP3 player for times that require portability (the car, the gym etc.) combined with vinyl for the peak experience at home. If you’ve got vinyl and an MP3 you’ve got everything you had with the CD but the artwork is larger and the sound is warmer and somehow more intimate. Plus listening to a CD (or MP3 for that matter) is a common daily background activity but listening to vinyl is an event.

Does vinyl really sound better?
This is an extremely subjective question that’s really hard to quantify.
The stances most folks take when they speak of vinyl’s superiority
is that vinyl is an analog sound wave, but a CD is a digital sound
wave. Simply put, music in an analog form consists of one continuous
flowing wave of data, where digital music consists more of dots that
are very close together forming something resembling a wave (but
isn’t). These days digital music has made great strides and they can
get those little dots so close together that most can’t hear a difference.
Unfortunately, most MP3 files are low bit rate and have a more
dramatic difference in sound. Higher
bitrates files require more hard drive or
iPod space than standard lower bit rate
files so many steer clear of those. The
difference really lies in the experience,
listening to a record is like going to a
movie theater; you can watch TV, DVD,
Blu-Ray or whatever, but the experience
is never quite the same as when you go
to the theater. You’re somewhat forced to focus on the film. Most folks tend to pay more attention when listening to a turntable even if it’s for the simple fact that you’re waiting for the last cut of that side so you know when to flip the record.
but what if i recorded my tracks with pro tools?
Keeping what was mentioned above in mind (an analog wave versus
digital) a lot of people like to question if vinyl can really sound better
than the CD if they both came from a digital source like Pro Tools. This is another spot where preference comes into play. These days CDs seem to be the most common source materials for lacquers, compared
to the 1/4”, 1/2” tape or DAT tapes from years past. Would the records
sound better if all the recording and mixing sources were analog like in
the past? Probably. Again, the movie theater analogy works here. Take
a film like The Blair Witch Project (shot on video) or Star Wars: Attack
of the Clones (shot digitally) – did you enjoy those more at home or at
the theater? Most theaters these days are still using film projectors so
the odds are very good that if you saw them on the big screen you saw
them on film (an analog medium). In the case of Blair Witch you saw a
picture that was converted from video (a poor analog source) to film;
while bumping from a bad medium to a great one didn’t suddenly recreate
the film in wondrous Technicolor
beauty, it was still unexplainably better.
In the theater you’re probably not going
to be flipping through your mail during
the slow parts or answering your phone
but you’re completely focused on the
film. You’re probably not going to play
a record while you’re doing something
labor intensive either but when you’re
ready to sit and really listen you put on
some vinyl. The film Star Wars: Attack
of The Clones, which was shot digitally then transferred to film (just
like transferring CD to LP) gave the theatrical version more of a real or
human feel. Personally, I like the occasional flaw that pops up on the
screen at the movie theater just like I appreciate the occasional crackle
of an LP. It just somehow makes it more human, you can see how it
works and just like seeing a band live it might do something unexpected.
There’s just something warmer about vinyl: the sound, the artwork,
the liners and some unexplained magic when you put the needle down.
who’s actually buying vinyl these days?
From what I see and hear it’s really becoming a mishmash of folks. For
the last few years it seemed like it was just the diehard audiophiles
and DJs. These days, more and more people are rediscovering vinyl
because they’re looking for something more tangible with better quality
than the low bit rate MP3s. The segment that seems to really be
booming right now is the rock market, more specifically metal and indie
rock. But all genres seem to be picking up as more and more people do
like I did… just realize one day that you’re only holding onto your CDs
for the art, liners and better quality for home… then remember that all
of that gets better with vinyl. As silly as it sounds, that really was my
thought process. I didn’t buy much vinyl in the 90s but now all current
music I buy is on vinyl and I’m replacing all my 90s & early 2000s CDs
with vinyl.
so are records going to replace CDs now?
As much as I love vinyl, I know it’s not for everyone. To me buying vinyl
is like buying box sets. People who buy box sets are not casual music
listeners and they know the value of having great packaging, liner notes
and such. While vinyl sales are growing I don’t expect it to be the
dominant format any time soon, just a favorite for folks who appreciate
great sound and packaging.
ok, i’m interested.
now help me understand how i do this.
The first step in the process is the mastering which
is really the all encompassing word for mixing,
EQ-ing and sequencing the record. Mixing, EQ-ing,
etc., should be done prior to sending your DAT
or CDR source to us to press your records. The
source you send to United should sound like you
want the music to sound on vinyl, sequenced in
order with the correct spacing between each song and a longer space
between sides. In ideal situations (i.e. just after winning the lottery)
you’d record on reel-to-reel then have it mastered on analog equipment.
There are things that experienced engineers do differently
when mixing for vinyl. So in a perfect world it’s AAA (analog recording,
mixing and output). For those of you who remember when CDs first
came around they all had codes on the package that said AAD (analog/
analog/digital) or ADD (analog/digital/digital). These days a lot of the
vinyl could come out with a DDA on it because lots of it is recorded
and mixed digitally before being transferred to vinyl. I bet most of you
(like me) couldn’t notice much of a difference. I see a lot of CDs come
in as sources for lacquers and those records still sound warmer and far
superior to me compared to CDs.
lacquer mastering
This is the art of taking your source material (tape, DAT, CD, etc) and
transferring it onto a lacquer. The lacquer is sort of like a softer waxier
version of the record that’s used to create the metal parts that eventually
become the stampers that make your records. The lacquers are
coated with silver and electroplated to make hard nickel plates which
become the masters. The masters are like metal versions of the inverse
of your record, instead of grooves they have ridges. The masters are
used to create “mothers” which are metal versions of your record that
can be used to create stampers. These stampers are sort of the molds
that create your records, like the masters these have ridges instead of
groves and these ridges press the grooves into your record.
time constraints
At URP we strongly suggest limiting the amount of music you put on
a record to help insure that you get a quality product. Cramming too
much music on a side can really lower the quality of your record and
increase the possibility of damage or sound issues. We generally say
a 12” record can hold up to 18 minutes of music per side at 33 1/3 rpm,
and up to 12 minutes per side at 45 rpm. A 7” record at 33 1/3 rpm can
hold up to 6 minutes per side. However, if your
music is fairly bass-heavy, you may want to shoot
for a maximum of 4:30 per side in order to insure
optimal sound quality. At 45 rpm, a 7” record
can hold up to 4:30 per side, or 3:30 per side for
recordings with heavy bass.
Simply put, RPM is an acronym for Revolutions Per Minute; so a 45
RPM record travels around 45 full rotations in a minute and a 33 1/3
record goes around 33 1/3 times. The reason for the different times is
basically the trade off of space versus quality. Cutting your lacquers
at 33 1/3 allows you to fit more music on your record but cutting it at
45RPM is believed to be a superior sound quality. A recent example
is the new Metallica reissues which are available two ways, as a single
LP at 33 1/3 RPM or a “Deluxe Edition” double LP cut at 45 RPM. More
audiophile recordings are coming this way and are sacrificing a little
convenience (by spreading the material over two LPs) in favor of sound
quality. Rhino was smart with the way they did it, making both available
since there are the two different schools of thought.
matrix numbers
Matrix numbers are the series of letters & numbers etched into the
“dead wax” between the label and the music. These numbers will
sometimes help trace back where a record was mastered or pressed.
For example, if you ever pick up a Beatles 45 that’s on Vee Jay Records
and it has an “SO” in the matrix number it means it was pressed in the
same building that URP still presses in now.
Ok, this one’s a little obvious but it sets up a little known fact I like.
Labels are in the center of your record and are the paper circles that
usually indicate the artist, title and side (A or B) of the record you’re
listening to. They often contain the song titles too. A little known fact
about record labels is that they contain no adhesive, but are pressed
into a record while the vinyl is hot and the hot vinyl essentially melts
into the pores of the paper keeping it in place.
jackets & sleeves
Although some folks have trouble keeping the
terms separated, sleeves are the paper covering
over your record before you place it into its
cardboard jacket. Most sleeves these days are
plain white ones with a hole so you can see the
label. Some folks splurge on custom sleeves with
art, lyrics or liner notes on them. Although there
are lots of options for jackets, there are basically
two standards – the single pocket and the two pocket gatefold, both of
which are made of cardboard. A lot of the DJ 12” singles are done with
generic black or white jackets with a hole in them that displays the la8
bel. Stickers are printed and applied to identify the record, key singles,
barcodes and such.
There are lots of cosmetic options for your records. Depending on
where you’re getting your records pressed you can choose between
various solid colors, transparent colors, swirls, the marble look or
picture discs. It’s a commonly held belief that there’s a drop in sound
quality when you stray away from black vinyl; lighter colors and clears
especially… followed by an additional drop off when you go to picture
disc. There are two schools of thought on why black vinyl sounds best,
one is that it’s the purest and contains no color additives. The other
school of thought is folks putting an emphasis on the lead content
present in most black vinyl. Black vinyl does indeed contain a small
amount of lead and it very well may play a part in the sound differences.
Admittedly, I don’t have much background in terms of picture discs
but from what I understand the production process is much different
than regular vinyl records and that the compound used is closer to PVC
plastic than it is to vinyl. Like most things with records it’s just a choice
you have to make as to which is more important to you the best sound
quality possible or a cooler presentation. Personally, when I’m in the
record shop having to decide between the 180 gram version of Velvet
Underground with Nico or the version on banana yellow vinyl I go with
the colors but many chose otherwise.
free cd inside?
…will it warp my records?
When the first creative folks got the idea to include a free CD inside
a vinyl record there was a bit of a scare that the presence of the CD
warped the record. Initially it was a valid concern as most records are
still cooling a bit when placed into the record jacket and the presence
of the CD against a warm record did cause warping but trial and error
got most folks over that hump as just changing the process a bit and
allowing the records to cool more all but eliminated the problem. Some
vinyl jacket vendors have jackets with pockets made specifically for
CDs and a few of them are designed in ways that drastically reduce
the chance of it warping. Obviously going with MP3s eliminates this
problem too but you can’t listen to that MP3 on your way home from
your favorite record store.
sizes & shapes & grooves
Your standard records are round with diameters of 7” 10” or 12”s. Some
manufacture records in various shapes too, I don’t know too much
about those. Most rock singles come out on 7”s usually at 45 RPMs
for the superior sound quality of that speed. On the other hand, most
dance, hiphop and R&B singles tend to be on 12” vinyl due to the ability
to space the grooves a little further apart (assuming they’re only putting
a song or two on a side). Because there’s generally less music on a 12”
single compared to a full length LP (long player) the grooves can be
spaced out making them easier to maneuver for those who like to mix &
scratch when DJing.
weights (180 gram, 210 gram, oh my)
First off, the weight of the record is just that. Most standard 12” records
are around 120 to 130 Grams in weight and they go up from there to
180 Gram or recently even 210 Grams. Most 7”s are pressed to be
between 30 or 40 Grams. Recently, 48 Gram 7”s have been offered
too which I love because it feels like those old Fisher Price records I
had when I was a kid. Many audiophiles speak of the superior sound of
heavier weight records but like most sound comparisons again it’s hard
to quantify and is thus debated. Could it be the change in vibration
or something…? Maybe, I wish I could tell you. One thing that doesn’t
seem to be debated is that the heavier weight records have more of a
physical presence and feeling of quality and also are less likely to warp.
etched vinyl: it looks amazing, just don’t play it.
Lately we’re seeing a lot more etched vinyl in the market. Recent releases
from the likes of Portishead, Of Montreal, Arcade Fire & Willie Nelson
have been offering an etched vinyl side to their records. Etched vinyl is
an unplayable side of a record that contains no music but has an image
pressed into it which has sort of a frosted appearance. There are no
colors pressed into it, it’s a similar look to a frosted window. In the case
of Portishead they used an etched vinyl image as the B
side to one of their recent singles. In the case of Willie
Nelson, he had too much music for a single LP but not
quite enough for a double so he pressed three sides of
music but used an etched image on the 4th side.
in closing…
There are lots of things to consider before pressing your
records. Most of the choices unfortunately have you choosing between
sound quality (black vinyl, heavy weight vinyl, analog sources, 45 RPM)
or uniqueness/convenience (colored vinyl, CD as a souce for lacquers,
33 1/3 RPMs). You’re never going to make everyone happy so go with
what makes you happy, then be proud of it and promote it. Make sure
you promote your features (color, etchings, downloads), on your website,
sales sheet or stickered on the jacket as it can really make a difference
to consumers… I know it does to me. Would Cracker Jack bother to put
a free toy inside without stating “free toy inside?” …you wouldn’t want
someone choking on your download card would you?
about me and urp
After doing tours of duty at PolyGram, BMG, SonyBMG and Universal I
moved to Nashville in 07 to become the Sales and Marketing Manager
for United Record Pressing.
United Record Pressing (URP) began in Nashville, Tennessee in 1949, when
it was known by the name Southern Plastics. One of their top clients was
Vee Jay Records out of Chicago, who pressed some of the first Beatles 7”s
in America, prior to Capitol signing them. In 1962, Southern Plastics relocated
to its current site, the same location that pressed those Beatles 7”s.
The company would eventually change its name to United Record Pressing
in 1971.
The company still operates out of that same plant and now gives tours to
the public, including the Nashville Gray Line Tour. In addition to seeing
how records are pressed visitors get a chance to see some southern history
including an apartment built above the factory to accommodate the label
execs of Vee Jay and Motown. The apartment was built out of necessity as
there were few hotels who would offer their services to people of color in
the 60s. There’s a lot of history to URP and they’re still very relevant today
as they remain the largest vinyl manufacturer in the country.

Leave a Reply

Your email address will not be published. Required fields are marked *